Can Johannesburg’s Decay be Blamed on its Mayors?
Kris van der Bijl
– November 15, 2026
6 min read

Let’s tackle an assertion made during the Johannesburg mayoral race in 2026 that the city needs a strong mayor to fix its many ills. Of course, each candidate presents themselves as the legitimate solution or saviour. Voters, too, naturally want to believe their ballot can influence their surroundings. But does the need to fix the city come from the mayoral office? Has Johannesburg faltered only because of a poor choice of mayor? Were its glory days, whenever those may have been, really the result of a person with a chain around their neck?
To say history can help us to understand the gradual crumbling of the present is not novel. But it remains annoyingly comforting. A recent account of Joburg’s 108 mayors makes the point that “through an appreciation of history, we understand that we are not stuck in a grim, eternal present”.
The line comes from the book Johannesburg’s Mayors: 140 Years of Making and Breaking the City, a serious and absorbing book written by academic Philip Harrison and writer Christopher McMichael, and published by Jacana Media in October 2026. As the title suggests, the authors cover 140 years of Johannesburg through the stories of its 108 mayors, right through the city’s formation as a gold rush capital to the zenith of Dada Morero. Over that period, the City of Gold has lived through global turmoil, apartheid, and the reconciliation efforts that followed, strikes for causes we no longer recall, and, as one mayor put it, “utterly selfish” drivers clogging its streets.
The role of Johannesburg’s mayor has changed considerably over time. Initially more honorary than it is today, the position was once held for a single one-year term. The first person to wear Joburg’s mayoral chain was Sir Henry “Harry” Graumann, elected in 1909, who had made his fortune speculating in the ostrich-feather trade, then a booming South African industry that declined through no real political fault. He was also the city’s first Jewish mayor. Interestingly, Johannesburg has technically though disingenuously had more Jewish mayors than either New York or Tel Aviv.
The 1913 miners’ strike offers a revealing glimpse of Johannesburg’s early mayors, their relationships with citizens and the kind of city Johannesburg was, and arguably still is. The mayor at the time, William Boustred, kept his head away from the crowds. But a past mayor named Charles Chudleigh found himself at the centre of the violence. A wealthy department store owner, Chudleigh was spotted on the balcony of the Rand Club as the Crown’s Dragoon Guards opened fire on striking workers. Rumours quickly spread that Chudleigh had also fired into the crowd, killing two men and two women. He splenetically denied the accusation, but the anger of the crowd was such that his department store was ransacked and a crowd marched on his Parktown mansion, which was saved by the arrival of cavalry.
Tension
This scene illustrates a tension that Harrison and McMichael develop throughout the book. In a city of national and international importance, both national and global forces have a stake. The book’s chapter-by-chapter structure illustrates this tension. Each chapter opens with developments in the wider world before narrowing its focus to the city. It presents a city both affected by the world and country beyond it, but still with agency to bear some responsibility. That structure is the book’s best decision, turning what could have been a roll-call of 108 mayors into a sustained account of just how much lies beyond the mayoral office.
Tension in the book ramps up when South Africa felt the disapproving weight of the world during apartheid. Within the city, the National Party (NP) sought greater control over municipal government, while townships such as Soweto fought for recognition as integral parts of Johannesburg.
The authors single out Johannes Francois “Obie” Oberholzer, a conservative United Party councillor representing working-class Rosettenville. They describe him as “a bulwark against the NP’s inroads” into former Labour Party territory. His opposition to the NP made him an important counterweight to the party advancing apartheid within the city government. Yet, ironically, some of the strongest resistance came from townships such as Soweto, whose residents were excluded from Johannesburg’s mayoral politics but nevertheless exerted an important influence on the city from outside its formal political structures.
At the end of apartheid, what it meant to be a mayor in Johannesburg shifted. The one-year terms gave way to Isaac Mogase’s five-year mayoralty in the transitional metropolitan government. In 2000, Johannesburg was restructured as a single metropolitan authority, with an executive mayor and unified local government. The city reflected the initial post-apartheid boom and was often at the centre of it. In Harrison and McMichael’s view, the mayoral administration under African National Congress (ANC) leadership oversaw many significant projects. Soweto, for instance, received roads and basic municipal services long neglected. The idea of Johannesburg as a world-class African city gained currency. The job now meant service delivery and the city’s ambitions, a long way from the honorary post of 1909.
Parks Tau, current minister of trade and industry, receives special mention from the authors. They make the case that his administration carried on the good work that the ANC had been doing since taking office in 1994. Johannesburg was described by one senior official as being in a “sweet spot”, enjoying “political stability, a healthy capital budget and the confidence of the private sector”. Yet the authors also identify a growing disconnect between Tau and his political base, alongside concerns about patronage and the integrity of his administration. They also point out that broader dissatisfaction with ANC-style leadership under then President Jacob Zuma damaged perceptions of the party’s ability to run the city.
Losing the City
In 2016, the ANC lost its majority hold of the city, with the mayorship falling too. The Democratic Alliance (DA) jumped to install Herman Mashaba as mayor with coalition support. That coalition proved unstable. Mashaba resigned in 2019 after his fallout with DA leadership over its direction and his self-proclaimed “pro-poor” agenda. So began the revolving door which, alongside prolonged water cuts and failed service delivery, seems to be what we talk of when we talk of the city.
Harrison and McMichael have written a valuable book for our present, chiefly because their long view lets us judge mayors according to the circumstances in which they governed. But it also reaches the limits of their historicist approach. They do not present an answer from history of what a good mayor is. Their own history shows the right person may not be enough.
Yet they admit that finding the right person for the job is a matter of “existential urgency” for the City of Gold, and close the text with an image of the CBD as seen through Nelson Mandela Bridge as a potential method of signalling hope. My more modest hope, true to the book’s long view, is that future readers will find the revolving door of mayors over the past few years as extraordinary as the thought of a Dragoon cavalry charge through Parktown.
Kris van der Bijl is a writer and researcher from Cape Town, South Africa. His work has appeared in African Arguments, World Literature Today, and The Sociological Review Magazine.