Time to End the Misery at SAA

David Christianson

– November 17, 2026

5 min read

South Africa’s national airline has cost taxpayers an effective R110 billion over the past 20 years. It needs to be sold off as soon as possible for whatever the government can get.
Time to End the Misery at SAA
Image by Darren Stewart - Gallo Images

Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has had enough of South African Airways (SAA). Following his October Medium-Term Budget Statement, the National Treasury announced that the government would offer no further lifelines to the airline, adding that it had until February to find a buyer.

This has led to a pointed debate over the future of the airline, with its group corporate affairs executive, Mphilo Dlamini, pushing back against arguments that SAA must be privatised if it is to survive. But Dlamini’s argument looks rather like a request for an open credit line with the government. He argued that the airline needed credible long-term capitalisation, which may have been an adequate approach when it was first bailed out in 2007, but will no longer wash.

SAA has not turned a genuine profit since 2012. The airline has survived on repeated handouts. The total value of taxpayer monies transferred since the first payment, R744 million in 2007, and including government settlements of state guarantees, comes to a nominal R62 billion – a staggering R110 billion in 2026 rands.

SAA did report a small net profit for the year ending March 2025 (R30 million), the last year for which results are available. But it was only able to do so because the airline had sold one of its two prized landing slots at London’s Heathrow Airport in March 2025 for R1.17 billion. Stripping away the money generated from selling off this irreplaceable asset and it is clear that SAA’s core operations have been running at a massive loss (R996 million in 2024/25).

The government’s argument for repeatedly bailing out the airline is that it is an essential part of South Africa’s destination branding. The airline does indeed keep the country’s flag flying overseas. But if SAA vanished, other airlines would snap up lucrative routes, notably São Paulo and Perth. In any case, destination marketing cannot possibly justify this scale of spending. The national Department of Tourism spends less than R2.5 million a year to reinforce the national brand.

In April, the Auditor-General issued a disclaimed audit opinion for the airline and stated that expenditure of at least R500 million was not accounted for. With soaring fuel costs in 2026, the National Treasury has had to step in yet again and, in August, provided a R1 billion credit guarantee to keep the airline flying. The government will almost certainly have to pay up when the guarantee comes due.

The vices of the state’s attempts to run an airline business have been starkly contrasted against the virtues of private aviation in recent weeks.

In late October, the Competition Tribunal approved the acquisition of FlySafair by private equity and infrastructure investor Harith General Partners for an estimated R7 billion. FlySafair is South Africa’s dominant domestic airline with more than 60% market share. In the same week, SAA announced it would have to stagger October salary payments due to cash flow pressures, the second consecutive month it has had to resort to this extreme.

Ironically, Harith was part of a consortium that offered to buy SAA in 2020. The initial bid (negligible cash upfront but a R3 billion cash injection into the operation) initially deemed adequate, given that SAA was broke, having generated no revenue at all during Covid-19. But as SAA seemed to recover (with the assistance of R30 billion from the National Treasury), the government asked for more. After three years, the deal fell apart over vastly different valuation assessments with the government asking for R5.5 billion upfront.

FlySafair is a privately owned company and is not required to make its financial results public. But it appears to have turned a profit every year except for Covid-stricken 2020, when no airline made money.

The contrast is striking. FlySafair started with two aircraft in October 2014, operating only on the Johannesburg-Cape Town route. When the airline began operations, it offered just eight flights a day, moving about 1 000 passengers. Today, it has expanded to 36 aircraft, flies on all major domestic routes, and has diversified its offering to include a range of regional destinations (Mauritius, Victoria Falls, Zanzibar, and, most recently, Windhoek). It transports about 30 000 passengers a day. SAA transports less than one-tenth of that figure on domestic routes.

Airlines are notoriously difficult to run. Sir Richard Branson, founder of Virgin Atlantic, once said that “if you want to be a millionaire, start with a billion dollars and launch a new airline”. Commercial aviation operates on razor-thin profit margins (historically averaging just 1% to 3% globally), has sizeable fixed costs (aircraft leases, maintenance, and insurance must be paid regardless of whether a plane flies full or empty), and no control over its major expense, jet fuel.

As a budget airline, FlySafair has to run a tight ship. SAA, by contrast, has demonstrated no discipline, has repeatedly run into trouble, and turned to taxpayers for help. It still has assets that might interest a potential buyer, notably properties (hangers, land surrounding airports) and, above all, SAA Technical (SAAT). SAAT serves not only its parent company but also a wide range of third-party domestic, regional, and international airlines including Lufthansa, KLM, Air France, Emirates, Qatar Airways, and British Airways.

There are no signs that SAA has re-established commercial viability let alone a credible long-term capitalisation strategy. It appears to be as hooked as ever on infusions from the public fiscus. The future is murky, as Godongwana has not said what will happen if the airline fails to find a buyer. No matter, the time has clearly come for a decisive break.

More articles by David Christianson

WE MAKE SOUTH AFRICA MAKE SENSE.

HOME

OPINIONS

POLITICS

POLLS

GLOBAL

ECONOMICS

LIFE

SPORT

InstagramLinkedInXFacebook