Reversing the Neocon Aberrations After the 3 November Disaster
Koos Malan
– November 17, 2026
7 min read

The midterm elections of 3 November in the United States (US) were a disaster for the Republican Party and President Donald Trump. Equally, and more seriously, they were a significant setback for the Western civilisation factor in the US and for the fate of the West wherever there is a Western presence.
Let's consider this four-pronged issue.
Trump
Trump, first of all, must bear considerable responsibility for this loss. With foolish assistance from within his own ranks, and encouraged even by praise singers here in South Africa, Trump is ultimately the author of this setback. Moreover, the US president might even be a spent force. The trouble that awaits him over the next two years in the face of a hostile Congress (from refusal to confirm his appointments, and financial gagging to the risk of impeachment for Trump personally and several of his ministers, and so on) means that the Trump presidency has just lost many more degrees of freedom to govern effectively.
The Republican Party
Second, the damage this election is causing to the Republican Party is much more serious and long-lasting. In the best-case scenario, it will take several years for this defeat to be overcome and for Republicans to return to the steering seat in Congress.
The Cultural Character of the US
The adverse outcome of the election for Republicans is reflected in a third, potentially even more devastating consequence. It concerns the cultural character of the US. The biggest and decisive question for the US is whether it is a Western state or simply culturally agnostic. If it is the latter, then far from being the world’s most important source of Western renewal, America is quite possibly the world’s most formidable anti-Western force, far more than any external threat to the US.
In the ideological sense of the word, the US has always been fundamentally liberal. This is evidenced by its belief in individual freedom and its principled commitment to equality since its founding.
The constitutional amendments after the Civil War (1861-1865), especially amendments 14 and 15, constitutionalised racial equality and, on the whole, removed the anomaly of racial inequality from the constitutional order.
The Civil Rights Act of 1964, coupled with the Civil Rights Movement, further removed remaining inequalities related to racial inequality. This, in conjunction with affirmative action and the new Immigration Act of 1965, unleashed a completely new dynamic that is ongoing to this day. On close analysis, it ushered in a new constitutional dispensation, as some like author Christopher Caldwell have argued quite convincingly.
This dynamic involves an ideological movement that ultimately aims to bring about the complete cultural or civilisational transformation of the US, often bolstered by emboldened federal power.
The unspoken assumption has always been that the US is a Western state; that it, together with western Europe and a few smaller centres elsewhere, constitutes Western civilisation; and that when push comes to shove, the US and its civilisational kin in Europe (and elsewhere) are dependent on each other to defend their common culture.
However, since the mid-1960s (the period that Canadian philosopher Charles Taylor identifies as the beginning of postmodernism), the assumption that the US is Western (that it is anchored in Western culture) has been steadily eroding.
By the middle of the second decade of the current century, the anti-Western force in the US was in full swing and seemed to peak during the Biden administration (2020-2024). This was expressed in vast waves of legally permitted and illegal non-Western immigration to the US and the worst excesses of leftist-progressivist ideology, the most heinous of which was reckless gender reassignment and genital mutilation of children, among other woke (cultural Marxist) craziness.
Trump’s success in the presidential election of November 2024 was largely thanks to the projection of boundless self-confidence (and necessary brutality) against the leftist revolutionaries, thereby restoring confidence to his own supporters who voted in large numbers for the Republican Party, to the extent that Trump was victorious in the swing states and also won the popular vote.
Trump, a remarkably unreflective politician, may not have fully understood the cultural implications of his own victory. However, many political figures around him, such as Vice-President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, thoroughly understood the implications of the victory for the cultural character of the US as well as for Western civilisation in general. So, of course, did many figures in and around the Republican Party, as well as in foundations, academia, and journalistic circles.
The second Trump administration began in January 2025 with a mixture of wisdom and folly. From the perspective of a Western civilisationalist like myself, there were clearly many favourable initiatives.
The new administration directly and indirectly endorsed and began to defend the US as a Western state. The cultural Marxism, symbolised by woke, was stopped in its tracks, but by no means fully neutralised. The demographic disruption of the US due to unbridled non-Western influx was also stopped, often unfortunately in ways that created harsh optics.
Western Civilisation
In its foreign policy, the new administration in the US therefore identified itself closely with Western civilisation and sought alliances with Western-minded forces in western Europe and elsewhere. This was an integral component of the new government’s Make America Great Again (MAGA) agenda. The US has also aligned itself with conservative parties in Europe. This includes the German Alternative für Deutschland of Alice Weidel and Tino Chrupalla, and the French Rassemblement National of Jordan Bardella and Marine Le Pen, and other similar ideological allies.
The new regime favoured American domination of the western hemisphere, distancing itself from American wars far beyond its borders and from the export of imperialistic-inspired liberal democracy and human rights based on neocon beliefs, which are strong in both the Republican and Democratic parties.
The unequivocal identification with the Western civilisational identity is best demonstrated in four documents: Vance’s speech at the Munich Security Conference on 14 February, 2025, Rubio’s speech at the same event in 2026, the National Security Strategy of December 2025 and Rubio’s speech on October 7 at the Acropolis in Athens. The second and third are, in my opinion, the highlights of this.
Then, for reasons that will not be discussed here, the US, contrary to its own policy and MAGA commitments, became involved in the war against Iran on 28 February this year. As many (including Professor John Mearsheimer and Robert Pape) had warned, this was predictably an enormous blunder, ultimately to the detriment of the US and the Republicans themselves. The war, as we all know, caused enormous adverse economic consequences for large parts of the world, including the US itself.
Following its adverse effects on the American people, the war became increasingly unpopular and caused enormous resistance to Trump, so great that no matter what efforts Trump himself and the Republicans might have made, they could not prevent the devastating defeat on 3 November. The Republicans themselves lost the most seemingly safe red states.
Correction
If the Democrats take over the White House in the next presidential election and expand their hold on Congress and the majority of states, this does not bode well for the US as a Western state. This could permanently alter the US’s demographic composition and, indeed, mark the beginning of the end of the US as a Western state. Of course, this also has a profound disadvantage for the rest of the West, which can draw much of its inspiration from the US.
Yet this election is not a death knell for Republicans and for the US as a Western state. The crux of the matter is that the outcome is not primarily a consequence of Democratic or broader leftist achievement, but rather the result of the failures of the Trump administration, and more specifically of Trump himself, to resist powerful interests in Washington baying for war in the Middle East. It could have been prevented, and it can be reversed. The vast majority of Americans still support the basis on which Trump won in 2024, but not the serious aberrations since. Republicans will essentially have to return to that sound basis.
To that end, potential presidential candidates who may be successful in the next presidential election may have to distance themselves from Trump and the misguided path he took, especially since February this year, and explicitly reject the neocon pressures. The America First policy and the Western foundation of domestic and foreign policy will have to be rehabilitated.
It is likely that we will soon see the first steps in that direction.