Sandpapergate 2.0: The Cover-up That Won’t Stay Buried
Sports Desk
– November 21, 2026
3 min read

In March 2018, Australia arrived at Newlands in Cape Town for the third Test of a four-match series against South Africa with the series level at 1-1, having won the first Test in Durban and lost the second in Port Elizabeth.
On day three in Cape Town, TV cameras caught Australian opener and relative newcomer to the Test side, Cameron Bancroft, rubbing the ball with sandpaper. The cricket world exploded, and Cricket Australia responded quickly. Captain Steve Smith, his deputy David Warner, and Bancroft were sent home in disgrace, with Smith and Warner both stripped of their leadership roles in the team. A Cricket Australia investigation found them to be the only three players with prior knowledge of the ball-tampering plot. Smith and Warner got year-long bans and Bancroft got nine months.
On the field, the collapse was total: Australia lost the Test by 322 runs, were dismissed meekly for 107 in the fourth innings, and then lost by 492 runs in Johannesburg in the fourth Test. South Africa took the series 3-1, their first home victory over Australia since 1970. The official story was that three men went rogue, were punished, and the matter was closed.
That story has now fallen apart. In his autobiography Sabr, Usman Khawaja, who had played in the Cape Town Test and played 88 Tests for Australia before retiring earlier this year, claimed that Australia had been ball-tampering in the second Test in South Africa, and not just at the third in Cape Town. He also wrote that the whole squad knew about the plan. He says Cricket Australia’s investigators had not interviewed him.
Current captain Pat Cummins, who was part of the 2018 side, in a press conference last week called Khawaja’s account “complete and utter nonsense”. Warner took the opposite view. He called the original investigation “rushed and botched”, and backed Khawaja in full. Chadd Sayers, another member of the 2018 touring party, whose first and only Test came in the fourth Test of that series, has also rejected Cummins’s version of events.
Then Bancroft spoke. In an essay published in The West Australian this week, he said far more players knew about the tampering than the three who were punished. He admitted he had held back key details from the original investigation, including when the tampering started, how long it went on for, and how many players knew, so that he would not implicate anyone else. He opened with: “In 2018, not the entire truth was told.” Bancroft said Cummins’s press conference was what finally pushed him to speak.
That puts Australia’s current captain directly at odds with two former teammates, three weeks before a home Test summer. Cricket Australia chairman David Boon has backed Cummins and said his job is not under threat. Chief executive Todd Greenberg has ruled out reopening the case. Instead, Cricket Australia is offering an independent forum where any player can give his account of what happened. The forum will not finish before the first Test against New Zealand on 9 December, and Bancroft says he will attend.
This is where the scandal gets worse than the cheating itself. Ball tampering is common in cricket, and South Africa, England, Pakistan, and India have all been caught at it. The real damage comes from how it was handled.
A governing body that names three culprits and then refuses to test new evidence protects its own version of events and calls that closure. If Khawaja and Bancroft are right, the latter’s career was sacrificed on the altar of expediency with Smith and Warner’s reputations being damaged, simply to save an institution’s reputation. If they are wrong, Cricket Australia should be keen to prove it. A forum with no power to punish anyone will satisfy neither side.
Whatever comes out of this, Australian cricket comes out looking weaker, and none of the players who were involved in the 2018 series emerge with their reputations intact. Australian cricket will now need to find a way forward, but it may have to be without their captain, Cummins, whose position looks increasingly untenable.