The Common Sense’s Diary

The Editorial Board

– November 4, 2026

5 min read

The election does not matter so much, it is still worth fighting for the Union, today just one in ten people will vote ANC, don’t do a CINO, screaming petulant child, the US did not terminate AGOA, when 2+2=yellow, dire stupidity on the Treasury, thank you Thabo Mbeki Foundation.
The Common Sense’s Diary
Image by Sharon Seretlo - Gallo Images

The election does not matter as much as some people think, as its result won’t change the kind of country South Africa is or the regime change process the country is moving through. That process is the evolution from a union to a fragmented enclave state. Too many people are looking for what new political regime will replace the old ANC regime to run South Africa from the Union Buildings. The likelihood is that the regime change taking place is one from central political control to enclavisation.

It is still worth fighting for the Union, and in a minority case it may still be saved. But that will require a pact between the middle class and the aspirant middle class, currently represented best by the DA and ANC, respectively, in government, and for both parties to be united around a workable reform strategy capable of lifting the investment rate by around 10 percentage points. None of that is currently in place. The ANC is split on working with the DA. The DA, rightly, is cautious of entering into deals that are not stable. And neither party has the full suite of necessary reforms in its thinking, let alone the question of agreeing on a common reform strategy.

To think how much has changed, consider that today just one in ten of the country’s voters will vote for the ANC. Thirty years ago it was almost six in ten. Cyril Ramaphosa has been going around saying he thinks everything is going very well and the ANC will be victorious.

But what must not happen is a CINO, or Coalition in Name Only. That will be destructive for both the ANC and the DA. The DA will be quite discredited in the minds of South Africans as being as hopeless as the ANC has become. It’s better to do no deal than to do a deal that discredits the only deal that could, in the fullness of time, save the Union. Rather bide time and get the circumstances right for that longer-term deal. Running around like headless chickens, grabbing at any coalition that comes along, is a mistake. South Africans are tough. They’ll hold the place together for a time still.

Gareth van Onselen was wonderful on Gabriel Makin’s show, describing Herman Mashaba as a “screaming petulant child”. As only Gareth can, Johannesburg voters, he said, are faced with “a remarkable situation where you have a five-year-old child stamping his feet and screaming and saying the adult in the room is difficult to work with and the media are reporting on it like, ja you’re right, that adult is a real problem”.

The Americans have sunk AGOA, read the headlines. Not really. South Africa sunk AGOA with its wildly inept foreign policy. But AGOA also does not matter much. It contributes just 2% of exports, meaning that modest exchange rate fluctuations are more consequential. Insofar as any substantive trade loss has occurred, that arises from South Africa’s refusal to negotiate a trade and investment pact with the US.

The South Africans, of course, say they have been negotiating, but what does that mean in practice? Have they been earnestly addressing the precise and technical issues around reciprocity the US has raised? No. They’ve been trying to hold long-winded debates around social justice and transformation, utterly detached from the hard reality around which trade and investment talks need to revolve.

Talking to parts of the South African government is a bit like this. If you ask what 2 + 2 is and someone tells you “5”, that’s actually okay. It’s not 5, of course, but 5 is close to 4, so it’s possible to at least start a conversation. But ask the contemporary South African government on the subject of trade with the US and the answer they’ll give is “yellow”. What do you do with that? They’ll tell you they’re having a debate. It’s as detached as saying the ANC is doing quite well.

The DA says the loss of AGOA can be traced to the foolish and hostile foreign policy of the ANC. Careful there, chaps, your own Ryan Coetzee has been just as toxic and hostile to the US as Ronald Lamola, and the DA itself is now, in practice, as persona non grata in Washington as any anti-US ANC leader would be.

Dire stupidity is evident in too many places. A fundamental idiot has attacked the Treasury for its supposed austerity and argued that unless the state spent more, the economy would not grow. The government expenditure-to-GDP ratio is over 30%! That is 10 points too high! The budget deficit is four times the rate of economic growth! The government is positively profligate in its spending. The problem is not that the state does not invest enough but that it prevents the private sector from investing more. Take Starlink as the case in point. But, oh no, as the ANC, legacy media, and most of the Twitter commentariat are fond of parroting, they don’t want that in South Africa because they don’t like Elon Musk. Nor must South Africa succumb to US “demands” on reciprocal trade or property rights. The legacy media is wholly united behind the government on that. Replicate those examples thousands of times over and you see why growth is a quarter of the deficit. It’s like a compounding of stupidity over and over again.

Thabo Mbeki’s Foundation, via Dr Mbuyiseni Ndlozi, was kind enough to host Dr Frans Cronje for a podcast that was released earlier this week. Two people from different worlds discussing what has happened and what must now be done to save the Union to the advantage of all South Africa’s people. That is what South Africa needs.

More articles by The Editorial Board

More articles on Columns

WE MAKE SOUTH AFRICA MAKE SENSE.

HOME

OPINIONS

POLITICS

POLLS

GLOBAL

ECONOMICS

LIFE

SPORT

InstagramLinkedInXFacebook