Expropriation Without Compensation by Regulation: Seven Days to Lose Your Firearm

Gideon Joubert

– November 22, 2026

7 min read

The proposed firearm regulations could allow the state to take privately owned firearms without compensation, using a seven-day deadline and costly storage requirements to penalise law-abiding owners who miss a licence renewal date.
Expropriation Without Compensation by Regulation: Seven Days to Lose Your Firearm
Image by Tertuis Pickard - Gallo Images

Seven days

Under new draft amendments to the Firearms Control Regulations, that is how long a South African gun owner whose licence has lapsed will have to act. In those seven days, the owner must either get rid of the firearm and its ammunition, or hand both to a dealer or a police station and apply for a new licence. The Registrar must then be told, in writing, within 24 hours.

I own licensed firearms, as do hundreds of thousands of law-abiding South Africans. Any one of us could miss a date.

When the Registrar cancels a licence, the Firearms Control Act itself gives the owner 60 days to dispose of the firearm. A person whose licence the state has actively revoked gets two months. Someone who simply missed a renewal date gets one week.

At the end of that road, if the paperwork goes wrong, the firearm is forfeited to the state without compensation. Call it expropriation without compensation by the back door: not by an Act of Parliament, but by a regulation.

The effect may be unintended. It is no less damaging for that.

Seven Days, Then the Strongroom

Once a licence expires, the owner has seven days to sell, donate, destroy, deactivate, or surrender the firearm, or to store it with a dealer or at a police station and apply afresh. Future lapses must be followed by a new application within 30 days. Owners whose licences have already expired get two years from when the regulations take effect.

While the firearm sits in storage, nobody may use it, and the draft sets no deadline for the Registrar to decide. A farmer’s only means of protecting his family could sit in a strongroom for as long as the backlog lasts. Dealers charge for storage, as any business would, and the draft forces the owner into that cost while setting no limit on how long the state may take. Those fees can rapidly exceed the value of the firearm itself. It is a costly punishment for a citizen trying to set his paperwork right.

If the application is refused, the owner has 60 days to dispose of the firearm, or 60 days from the end of an unsuccessful appeal. Miss that window, and the firearm is forfeited to the state. No compensation is payable, except in the narrow case where the state keeps a firearm of special value.

Possession Versus Ownership

A firearm licence does not make you the owner of a firearm. You own it the way you own a car or a fridge: you bought it, you paid for it, it is your property. The licence is the state’s permission for you to possess it: to carry it, keep it, and use it lawfully.

When a licence expires, that permission ends. Your ownership does not.

This is not a gun owner’s talking point. It is the Constitutional Court’s reasoning. In Minister of Police v Fidelity Security Services, decided in May 2022, the court found that the Act regulates possession, not ownership. It held that nothing in the Act bars a new licence application for a firearm whose licence has lapsed, and that the Registrar must consider such applications. The Act itself says a forfeited firearm remains the property of its owner until it is destroyed.

The South African Police Service (SAPS) accepted this and began processing such applications in July 2022.

From Deprivation to Expropriation

Locking a firearm in a strongroom, and barring its owner from it while an application waits indefinitely, is a deprivation of property. The owner still owns it but cannot exercise any right of ownership, not even keeping a valuable asset safely in his own safe. This is an asset the state had no problem with him possessing until a renewal date passed. Under the Constitution’s property clause, a deprivation must be authorised by law of general application and cannot be arbitrary.

Consider the car again. If your licence disc expires, you risk a fine. The state does not make you hand your vehicle to a dealership or a government pound until you renew. Only firearms are treated this way for what amounts to an administrative infraction.

Forfeiture without compensation is something else entirely. It is not a limit on how you may use your property. It is the transfer of your property to the state. In plain terms, that is expropriation.

The draft does not frame it that way. It does not need to.

A Filter, Not a Deadline

A seven-day clock is not a neutral detail. It is a filter. Every owner who is travelling, ill, or slow to find storage falls through it. Picture the farmer again: a week to find a dealer with space in his safe, or a police station willing to take it, before his property starts slipping away. So does the owner who never noticed the card had expired, an oversight without malice or criminal intent, and likely the reason for most expired licences.

The 30-day filing window looks generous, but it is of little help to someone who has already fallen through the seven-day crack. A time limit that runs from the day the owner discovers the lapse would be far fairer.

Add storage that costs money and has no decision deadline, and forfeiture after refusal. Each step looks defensible on its own. Together, they turn a route the Constitutional Court said must stay open into a funnel with one exit: the loss of private property.

The rest of the draft follows the same instinct: medical and eyesight reports on demand, a 72-hour limit on security officers’ possession of company firearms, and new paperwork for non-citizens and dealers. None of it is aimed at the people who commit violent crime. The state’s own commissioned research, a report from the University of the Witwatersrand it sat on for six years, found that the Firearms Control Act is relevant to less than 5% of crime, and that strong policing, not more paperwork for licence holders, is what reduces firearm violence.

Criminals do not renew licences. They will not be storing anything with a dealer within seven days of expiration.

These regulations do not stand alone. Read them alongside the Firearms Control Amendment Bill, which would limit self-defence licences to “exceptional circumstances” and cap how many firearms a sport shooter may own, and a pattern emerges. One instrument narrows who may acquire a firearm. The other narrows how long an existing owner may keep one. Whichever door a law-abiding citizen comes through, the direction is the same: fewer lawful firearms in private hands.

The state lost its practical monopoly on force a long time ago. Neither measure tries to win it back. Neither touches the unlicensed firearm, the stolen firearm or the man who carries one with its serial number ground off. Both act only on the citizen who registered, paid and complied.

A state worried about criminals would aim at criminals. This one aims at the people who already answer to it. The unspoken message to law-abiding South Africans is to accept that criminals exist, and do as they please, and to give up any lawful means of standing against them.

The Court, Bypassed

Read as a whole, the draft is a credible threat, not yet a settled fact. It may be challenged or withdrawn, and its drafters will argue the minister has the power to make it.

There is good reason to formalise a route for owners with expired licences to bring themselves back in line with the Act. My objection is not that SAPS is responding to the Constitutional Court. It is how.

In 2022, the court told the state that an expired licence ends possession, not ownership, and that owners may apply again. Four years later, the state proposes to keep that door technically open while making it as narrow, as fast and as costly to walk through as possible, with confiscation waiting on the other side.

I am not a lawyer, but it takes no uncharitable reading to ask whether this is an ultra vires attempt to bypass, or at least blunt, a Constitutional Court judgment that went against the state.

Seven days to lose your possession. Sixty more to lose your property.

Every gun owner, and every South African who values property rights, should submit comments before 18 January 2027. The draft should be withdrawn.

Gideon Joubert is an independent security consultant focused on enterprise risk management, a certified fraud examiner and a member of ASIS International. He is a trustee of the South African Gunowners’ Association, as well as an active competitive sport shooter and handloader.

More articles by Gideon Joubert

More articles on Editorials

WE MAKE SOUTH AFRICA MAKE SENSE.

HOME

OPINIONS

POLITICS

POLLS

GLOBAL

ECONOMICS

LIFE

SPORT

InstagramLinkedInXFacebook