Pressure Might Still Save the GNU

Frans Cronje

– November 21, 2026

5 min read

The application of vast pressure on the ANC through this weekend and into next week might still save the GNU.
Pressure Might Still Save the GNU
Image by Brenton Geach - Gallo Images

It is a law of these things that pressure breeds reform. Over the past week, as the reality of a flip of the Government of National Unity (GNU) dawned on the country and its business community, and among other people of influence, the complacency that had been present in elite society dissipated, and pressure may now be applied that, even if it does not halt the drift of things, may dilute the extent to which that flip occurs.

Why was South Africa’s 1994 transition a success that delivered a market economy and a liberal democracy, relative to what might have been? Because Anglo American and its affiliates had, since the 1980s, mounted a vast effort to make it so. Why did 2007 happen and the defeat of Thabo Mbeki? Because business and people of influence had grown complacent that the existing status quo of sound growth and pragmatic-enough policy was solid. Why was the CR17 transition a success insofar as it returned a more pragmatic African National Congress (ANC) to government than what might have been? Because business and people of influence made it so. Why did the Democratic Alliance (DA)/ANC GNU occur? The same reason. Why has that GNU now almost been allowed to slip away? Because business and its related sources of influence were complacent in the run-up to the local government elections, thinking that the GNU was solid, that a weaker ANC would translate into a stronger DA and that this was reform-positive, and that Cyril Ramaphosa could be relied on to hold the GNU together.

It is universally true that if you turn your back on the political establishment and release the pressure, it will revert to type. And type is not always the best thing. That has been as true in South Africa as it has been for Boris Johnson in Britain or Donald Trump in America.

Last week, our firm raised the odds of a GNU flip to 75%. That was not a sudden departure but was very much in line with long-term advice through the year that the GNU was not as solid as it appeared and the assumptions of what a weakened ANC would deliver were wrong. That is the same line that was taken by this newspaper, which warned at intervals throughout the year that the underpinnings of the GNU were breaking and that the local election aftermath might end it; and you should read its September piece on whether South Africa was being mispriced on political risk here. That advice was taken on board by many who heard it, but the dominant sense of the thing was that this was a minority-case risk for the country and that the GNU would likely prevail.

That sense held in our experience until around Wednesday this week, when sentiment shifted. The reality of what was under way in the ANC camp and the coalition discussions suddenly loomed large in the business community, and with Mr Ramaphosa absent from South Africa during his visit to America, in the company too of his excellent finance minister, and with other key voices in the ANC also absent, concern has lifted markedly over the past 72 hours.

Throughout our analysis, the 75% odds have, of course, been matched by a 25% chance of a political outcome that might be more in line with what business and the investment community might prefer, chiefly in the form of a DA/ANC pact. Odds of 25% are pretty strong in a climate as obviously poisonous to the GNU as events last week were, but we justified the 25% on grounds of what late-stage pressure in the face of the emerging reality might yet achieve. A client note contained this statement, for example, that “it remains possible that the arrangement could be revised or reversed, especially if a very strong market or other reaction arises against it”. Another read, “key pragmatists who have been abroad are returning to SA and will start exerting influence through the weekend … the ANC is also concerned about the market … all now seem to agree that the clock is ticking down to Friday the 27th, so there is still a lot of time left, and our odds could move appreciably”.

The tricky thing here was always going to be the balance and timing of things. As long as business and the market remained complacent, the odds of a flip would remain high, but as soon as those odds peaked to near inevitability, the consequence would be to force the pressure that chased the odds down again. In other words, the thing had to be driven to the brink of occurring if there was to be a serious prospect of it not occurring.

Pressure works particularly well on the ANC camp because of the wise balance-of-forces framework the party uses to make decisions. In the absence of resistance, the party is required to advance its revolutionary agenda, with which the flipping of the GNU would be quite in line. In fact, not doing so when the opportunity is there falls into a category of what the ANC calls “right-wing opportunism” and is a political sin. However, in the face of determined resistance, the ANC is required to step back and cease its advance. Violating that guideline makes it guilty of “left-wing adventurism” that puts the whole revolution at risk should the resistance become organised and determined; obviously another political sin.

What market and related business pressure manifests over the next few days may yet flip the flip, and even if it does not do so entirely, it will dilute the extent of the severity of the flip and its aftermath, which, it must be added, the firm does not judge will be as severe as the market fears, for the reason that the reform agenda the GNU has been thought to underpin has in many respects been more apparent than real. The Treasury team will initially be left intact, and the JSE, the rand, and the bond market will simply come to be priced on value and fundamentals that should not, for a considerable time at least, be categorically different from what they have been over the life of the GNU.

More articles by Frans Cronje

More articles on Editorials

WE MAKE SOUTH AFRICA MAKE SENSE.

HOME

OPINIONS

POLITICS

POLLS

GLOBAL

ECONOMICS

LIFE

SPORT

InstagramLinkedInXFacebook