Is Mashaba Afraid of the DA, or Afraid of What Happens if it Succeeds?

Ruben van Niekerk

– November 21, 2026

6 min read

If working with the DA amounts to political suicide for ActionSA, perhaps we should ask what exactly Herman Mashaba believes his party has to lose.
Is Mashaba Afraid of the DA, or Afraid of What Happens if it Succeeds?
Image by Lubabalo Lesolle - Gallo Images

There is something rather interesting about ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba’s latest comments on the prospect of ActionSA entering a coalition with the Democratic Alliance (DA).

On 15 November 2026, Mashaba said on the social media platform X that if his party worked with the DA, it would be “gone”, adding: “Working with the DA is tantamount to committing suicide.”

In another X post, he said: “If ActionSA goes to bed with the DA, there won’t be ActionSA in 2029. The DA will take their destruction of ActionSA to the highest gear. ActionSA is not yet prepared to commit suicide.”

Those are fairly dramatic words for a man whose party has spent much of its political existence presenting itself as a credible alternative to the very political establishment he now appears willing to negotiate with.

But I think there is a more interesting question buried underneath his statement.

Why, exactly, does Mashaba believe that working with the DA would spell the end of ActionSA?

Is he genuinely concerned about the DA swallowing his party politically? Is he worried that a successful DA government would leave voters with little reason to support smaller parties? Or is there something else at play?

Perhaps the question is not whether the DA would destroy ActionSA, but whether the DA could make ActionSA unnecessary.

Political Reality

Let’s consider the political reality.

ActionSA was established in 2020 on the promise of offering South Africans something different. It positioned itself as an alternative to the African National Congress (ANC), while distinguishing itself from the DA. It wanted to occupy political space between the two, appealing to voters who were dissatisfied with the ANC but not necessarily convinced that the DA represented their interests.

That is a perfectly legitimate political strategy.

However, political space is not permanent. It is earned, contested, and, sometimes, lost.

The 2026 local government elections have demonstrated that South African voters are increasingly willing to reconsider their political loyalties. The ANC’s support has continued to decline, while the DA has strengthened its position in several important municipalities. ActionSA, meanwhile, finds itself in the rather enviable position of holding considerable bargaining power in hung councils.

And perhaps therein lies the problem.

What happens when the DA becomes a more convincing governing alternative? What happens when voters begin to see a party that can demonstrate its ability to govern, rather than simply promise that it would govern better?

Would ActionSA still have the same appeal?

If the DA can demonstrate that it can run municipalities effectively, improve service delivery, manage public finances, and tackle corruption, what precisely would ActionSA offer voters that they could not get from the DA?

That is not a suggestion that the DA is infallible. It certainly isn’t. But it is a legitimate question about political competition.

There is another possibility worth considering.

Perhaps Mashaba is less concerned about the DA’s electoral success than he is about what a coalition would demand of ActionSA.

Not as Forgiving

Opposition politics offers considerable freedom. You can criticise, campaign, promise and position yourself as the solution to almost every problem. Governing is considerably less forgiving.

When you enter a coalition, you inherit responsibility. You have to negotiate, compromise, make difficult decisions, and accept accountability for the consequences. You cannot simply distance yourself from every unpopular decision while claiming credit for every success.

If ActionSA were to govern alongside the DA, it would have to demonstrate that its promises can translate into actual policy and measurable results.

And that is where the electorate should be paying attention.

ActionSA has repeatedly presented itself as a party committed to fighting corruption, restoring effective local government and improving service delivery. These are not particularly controversial ambitions. In fact, they are precisely the kinds of commitments voters should expect from any party seeking public office.

So why would working with another party that publicly claims to share those objectives amount to political suicide?

Unless, of course, the concern is not about the objectives themselves, but about who gets to take the credit for achieving them.

There is also an uncomfortable contradiction in the way this coalition debate is unfolding.

Mashaba appears considerably more comfortable exploring an arrangement with the ANC than he does with the DA. ActionSA has engaged the ANC in coalition negotiations, despite having built much of its political identity around offering an alternative to ANC governance.

To be fair, Mashaba is entitled to negotiate with whomever he chooses. Coalition politics requires pragmatism, and no party should be expected to surrender its identity simply because it enters an agreement with another.

Both Ways

But that argument must work both ways.

If independence is the principle, it cannot suddenly become conditional on which party is sitting across the negotiating table.

If the ANC is an acceptable coalition partner, Mashaba should explain what makes that arrangement compatible with ActionSA’s founding principles, while a DA partnership supposedly threatens the party’s very existence.

And if the objection is specifically about individuals such as Helen Zille and Cilliers Brink, then perhaps the debate should be about those individuals rather than an entire political party.

South Africans deserve to know whether this is a disagreement about policy, political principles, personalities, or something far more strategic.

There is a difference between protecting your party’s independence and protecting its political relevance.

Perhaps Mashaba genuinely believes the DA poses an existential threat to ActionSA. Perhaps he has legitimate concerns about the party’s negotiating conduct and the possibility of being politically marginalised within a coalition.

Those concerns deserve to be heard.

But voters should also be allowed to ask whether ActionSA is more interested in building a government that works than in ensuring that ActionSA itself remains politically indispensable.

Because ultimately, political parties do not exist to preserve their own brands. They exist to represent voters and improve the lives of the people who put them in office.

If a coalition with the DA can deliver better government, why should that possibility be dismissed as political suicide?

And if a coalition with the ANC is the better option, then Mashaba should be prepared to explain precisely how it serves the mandate ActionSA received from voters.

Perhaps the greatest threat to ActionSA’s future is not the DA.

Perhaps it is the possibility that, somewhere along the way, the party has become more concerned about surviving as a political organisation than proving why it deserves to survive.

South Africans have had quite enough of political parties treating government as an exercise in preserving their own positions.

They need parties willing to put the country ahead of themselves.

And if that requires a little political suicide to get there, perhaps it is worth considering.

Ruben van Niekerk is a South African communications strategist, writer and political commentator.

More articles on Editorials

WE MAKE SOUTH AFRICA MAKE SENSE.

HOME

OPINIONS

POLITICS

POLLS

GLOBAL

ECONOMICS

LIFE

SPORT

InstagramLinkedInXFacebook