South African and American Elections Show that Voters are not Party Property

Nicholas Babaya

– November 16, 2026

4 min read

Recent elections in South Africa and America show that voters are increasingly willing to abandon political loyalties and punish governments for economic hardship, declining living standards, and poor governance.
South African and American Elections Show that Voters are not Party Property
Photo by Joseph Prezioso/Getty Images

Perhaps the most encouraging result from recent elections in South Africa and the United States (US) is not just that opposition parties won, but also that so many voters swung their support to punish the incumbents.  

Punishing dysfunctional governments at the ballot box is necessary for democracy to work. While many on both sides of the Atlantic might have given up on this idea, as politics can often appear to be tribal, the recent elections have demonstrated one fact to be true: you can’t govern badly forever and still expect to be re-elected.

In 2024, a whole range of voters swung to support Donald Trump, yet those same groups abandoned him in record numbers two years later. Fox News’s initial voter analysis reported Hispanic voters favoring Democratic House candidates by 27 points; a 15-point swing from 2024. Young men moved from a 15-point Trump advantage to a 33-point Democratic advantage, perhaps the largest swing of any demographic group within two years. It appears that many young voters, particularly men younger than 40, did not “belong” to either party and changed their votes in accordance with their living standards.

This backlash is no surprise to anyone who lives in America, as 89% of voters described the cost of living as a major or crucial factor in their choice. Following a prolonged period of low inflation and low interest rates in America, the economic picture since the onset of Covid-19 has not been nearly as upbeat. CPI inflation has grown to a cumulative 31% since January 2020, and high fuel prices have been particularly hard on a people who so love to drive long distances in large and powerful pickup trucks and SUVs.

Dire Picture

The housing market paints a particularly dire picture. American home prices skyrocketed during the pandemic, and the impact on this one particular asset class is now being felt across American society. The National Association of Realtors puts the median first-time buyer’s age at 40. That’s right, 40: an age once associated with an established household and career, not its first foothold in ownership. For many young men who seek to build families and be providers, the frustration with this fact, and that Trump’s trade policy has made it worse by hiking the prices of building materials and labour, likely reached a boiling point.

Trump’s answer has hardly reassured. His tariff agenda and the Iran war became electoral liabilities, with Republicans nationwide distancing themselves from both policies, but this appeared to have had little effect; the electorate was tired.

To South African readers, these statistics might sound benign compared with South Africa’s economic state, but Americans have shown time and time again their intolerance of any decline in living standards. From Jimmy Carter to Joe Biden, inflation has been lethal for the political career of any incumbent party.

Severe Dissatisfaction

In South Africa, the situation is far more severe. Many municipalities are unable to provide even the most basic services. Big cities have not been immune to this either; Johannesburg’s decline has been particularly palpable, as any resident will tell you. Its broken sidewalks, water outages, and potholes make it more closely resemble Harare than Cape Town, despite Cape Town being in the same country.

And so, for all these sins of bad governance, the incumbents received a shellacking. In the US, the GOP lost eight senators, including some in solid red states. Republican losses in states like South Carolina and Mississippi, previously not even discussed in the media as potential losses for the GOP, demonstrated the severe dissatisfaction that voters had with the Trump administration’s policies.

In South Africa, the African National Congress (ANC) received a similarly bruising verdict. Its share of the nationwide vote fell to about 30.0% in 2026. More strikingly, it failed to secure an outright majority in any of the country’s eight metros. In Johannesburg, its support sank to 20.1%, and in Tshwane, it finished third with 20.2%, behind the Democratic Alliance and ActionSA. In eThekwini, once an ANC stronghold, fewer than one in six voters made their mark for the ANC.

Back in the US, Democrats should resist the temptation to mistake this verdict for unconditional endorsement. It was only a few years ago that many of their reliable voters withdrew their support and helped re-elect Donald Trump. This time, the Democrats ran a highly disciplined campaign which was laser-focused on cost-of-living issues. Should they retreat from this discipline and descend into their pet interest issues, which concern only a tiny share of left-wing Americans, the GOP may easily claw back its support, especially if standards of living do not improve.

That is the democratic bargain: authority is temporary, performance matters, and allegiance is revocable. Without that back and forth, elections become competitions to excite an existing base. With it, citizens remain employers rather than followers. The recent results across both sides of the pond show that now, voters are far more willing to put tribalism aside and vote for their interests. This can only be seen as an encouraging and healthy sign for democracy in either country.

Babaya is a member of the Council of the Institute of Race Relations and formerly worked under Dr Frans Cronje at the Center For Risk Analysis. He resides in the United States.

More articles on Editorials

WE MAKE SOUTH AFRICA MAKE SENSE.

HOME

OPINIONS

POLITICS

POLLS

GLOBAL

ECONOMICS

LIFE

SPORT

InstagramLinkedInXFacebook