UCT’s Academic Freedom at Stake in Bid to Expel Council Member
Marika Sboros
– November 19, 2026
10 min read

Scholars from leading universities in the United States, Britain, Canada and Europe have penned an open letter urging the University of Cape Town (UCT) not to expel a member of its governing Council for his opinions expressed in a podcast.
They have asked the UCT Council to reject a recommendation by retired Judge Mahomed Navsa that Advocate Mark Oppenheimer be “disqualified” as a Council member. His offence, as the scholars see it, was publicly criticising university policy and raising concerns about antisemitism and threats to academic freedom.
Navsa also recommended that the Council suspend member David Ansara for six months for sharing someone else’s praise of Oppenheimer’s opinions.
UCT has long styled itself a bastion of academic freedom. Its Council is doing its best to prove otherwise.
The open letter’s signatories include Professor Brian Leiter of the University of Chicago, associate Professor Rebecca Tuvel of Rhodes College in Tennessee, Professor Nadine Strossen of New York Law School, and philosophers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and the universities of Stanford and Oxford. Two UCT academics, philosopher Elisa Galgut and palliative medicine lecturer Maggie de Swardt, have also signed.
Their support for Oppenheimer’s freedom of expression does not require agreement with his political views, his assessment of events at UCT or his choice of words. “These matters are open to vigorous disagreement,” they say.
The principle they defend is that “members of a university community must be free to question institutional policies and prevailing orthodoxies, including on subjects that provoke deep political and religious disagreement”.
In March 2025, Oppenheimer, an advocate at the Johannesburg Bar and co-host of a philosophy podcast, Brain in a Vat, appeared on the podcast of Ayaan Hirsi Ali, a Somali-born, Dutch-American author, a research fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution and outspoken critic of political Islam.
More than halfway through the interview, Oppenheimer referred to UCT’s academic boycott against Israeli academics, antisemitism on its campus, and “Islamist elements” that had taken control of the institution, terrorised those who disagreed with them and trampled on academic freedom.
He also referred to two “Gaza resolutions” that the Council adopted in June 2024. One bars UCT academics from research ties with groups affiliated with the Israel Defense Forces. The other rejects the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition of antisemitism.
UCT historian Professor Adam Mendelsohn has asked the Western Cape High Court to review the resolutions. The Council defends them as moral imperatives taken in solidarity with Palestinians. Judgment has been pending since the hearing in October 2025.
Complainants
Still, 13 complainants, several of them members of UCT’s Senate, called Oppenheimer’s remarks “Islamophobic” and false, and demanded sanctions.
Council appointed Navsa and retired Judge Malcolm Wallis to investigate some 50 complaints against various members. Wallis looked into three complaints including against Oppenheimer and dismissed all three.
Navsa took the remaining 47, including 24 against Oppenheimer over the podcast. He found that Oppenheimer had breached the Council’s Code of Conduct.
In extracts of his report published on Politicsweb, Navsa says, presumably without a hint of irony, that the case against Oppenheimer is “not a question of free speech or the boundaries between free speech and hate speech”. It is about “acting honestly, in good faith, with proper purpose and with respect for the institution and Council members”.
He also says there can be “no doubt that the statements made by [Oppenheimer] are seriously damaging and affect UCT’s reputation”.
Navsa is presumably aware that Council’s same conduct code requires members to be “respectful of every individual’s right to express their opinions, whether those opinions are complimentary or critical of Council and UCT”.
The open letter’s signatories respectfully disagree with Navsa. They argue that he finds against Oppenheimer because he judges his claims about a live public dispute false and insulting. When a governing body removes a member on those grounds, “it punishes speech, whatever it calls the offence”, they say.
Yet while questions of good faith, reputation and disclaimers did fall squarely within Navsa’s remit, whether UCT has succumbed to Islamist influence, or whether its resolutions amount to an academic boycott, did not.
The scholars argue that such questions belong in open debate, where colleagues who felt maligned had every right to answer him, in public and at length.
Defended
Oppenheimer has defended himself vigorously, as extracts from Navsa’s report show.
He denied that his remarks were Islamophobic, racist, or defamatory. He named no one, never called any supporter of the resolutions an Islamist or terrorist, and never claimed Muslims had captured UCT.
“Take control” and “terrorise” were conversational words, he said, meaning influence over campus life and intimidation of Jewish students, not that Senate voted under duress.
Oppenheimer called his boycott claim “substantially true”, because the resolution bars collaboration only with Israeli academics. He cited retired Judge Dennis Davis, who says it worked as a blanket ban of all Israeli academics, and UCT’s own 2019 legal opinion, which found such a boycott unlawful.
He distinguished Islamism, a political ideology, from Islam. He backed his claims with four campus videos, showing students chanting, “We are Hamas”, including a clip of students waving Hezbollah flags and Iranian regime flags, and of a Jewish student’s yarmulke being torn off.
Oppenheimer also described a surge in antisemitic incidents on campus after the Hamas terror attack on Israel on 7 October, 2023.
He is not the first to have noticed such things. A searing example is a video that the South African Union of Jewish Students compiled in March 2024.
Navsa rejected his campus-incidents defence as “baseless”, saying that student protests do not amount to control of the university.
Others have a more jaundiced view.
They recall the death by suicide in 2018 of Professor Bongani Mayosi, a renowned cardiologist and Dean of Health Sciences. UCT’s own inquiry found the Fees Must Fall student protests were “the single most influential factor” affecting his deanship.
His family said, “the vitriolic character of student engagements tore him apart”.
Council adopted both judges’ reports on 18 October. Two days later, Council Chair Advocate Norman Arendse published a statement on UCT’s website with links to the reports that were swiftly withdrawn. Arendse apologised. But not before they had been widely shared online.
Respectfully to Navsa, I’d say that the hornets’ nest UCT stirred by releasing the full reports has done far more damage to its reputation than Oppenheimer’s podcast comments ever could.
Double Standards
UCT has also damaged to its own reputation in recent years through blatant double standards.
Contrast its treatment of Oppenheimer with politics lecturer Dr Lwazi Lushaba, who told first-year students in 2021 that Hitler “committed no crime”. A UCT-appointed evaluation panel found that his lecture fell within academic freedom.
In March this year, Lushaba was at it again, telling students, “Hitler did nothing wrong”. His only “wrong was to do unto white people what white people have reserved for us black people”. He also told students that Jews who were victims of oppression in Germany “become advocates of oppression” in South Africa and Israel.
Lushaba has presented his remarks as a “critique” of Western scholarship’s indifference to black suffering. He still teaches at UCT while Oppenheimer faces expulsion.
Political economist Phumlani Majozi sees a pattern. “The problem with pro-Palestine movements is that they want to force others to interpret the world as they do. Disagree with them, and you must suffer,” he writes.
A lawyer close to UCT, who prefers to remain anonymous, says the “pro-Gaza faction” at UCT has been trying to get rid of Oppenheimer for years.
The chronology bears that out.
Alumni elected Oppenheimer to the UCT Council in 2024, and his term began in July that year. By December, some alumni had tried to get UCT’s Convocation to pass a motion calling for fresh elections for all four alumni-elected seats on Council.
The reason, says the lawyer, is simple: “His views on Israel.”
In March 2025, Oppenheimer called for a Council vote to rescind the Gaza resolutions. The vote did not pass. In the same month, he gave the interview to Hirsi Ali. His opponents now had their opening.
Those who voted for him knew exactly what they were getting, the lawyer says. It was “essentially written on Oppenheimer’s packaging” that he appears frequently on TV and radio and does interviews and podcasts online.
“Complaining about his views on podcasts is like complaining that a dog barks, knowing it is a dog.”
Council itself put Oppenheimer on UCT’s Academic Freedom Committee, where he still sits.
“Now they are finding fault with the very thing they valued in the first place,” the lawyer says.
Discourage
In their open letter, the scholars warn that removing an elected member for voicing concerns would discourage others from raising difficult questions. The letter’s initiator, Rebecca Tuvel, knows that cost first-hand.
In 2017, Tuvel was an untenured assistant professor at Rhodes College when the journal, Hypatia, published her paper “In Defense of Transracialism”. The social media backlash was intense.
Her sin? Asking why the reasoning behind accepting transgender identities does not extend to people who identify as another race.
More than 800 people signed a letter demanding the paper’s retraction. Some demanded that she be fired. Tuvel told Evan Goldstein of The Chronicle of Higher Education recently that she would almost certainly have left academia had colleagues, three brave feminist philosophers among them, not defended her.
She initiated the open letter, she says, because “a university must be a place that can host and model a clash of ideas, above all on the most heated topics, like Israel and Gaza.
“If it can’t manage that, it’s hard to see what it’s for.”
Academics abroad should care about what’s happening to Oppenheimer, Tuvel says, “because it’s the same dispute we’re having everywhere – universities censoring and excluding dissenting voices rather than engaging them”.
UCT’s graduates elected Oppenheimer “knowing he was a critic of the university’s direction. They wanted a critic on Council,” she says.
UCT’s Council has committed itself to “the creation of spaces for the contestation of ideas”. Contesting ideas matters because “every age has been confident about what justice demands, and hindsight has shown every age to be mistaken about some of it”, she says.
Tuvel recalls former Dutch Reformed Church minister Beyers Naudé, who was forced out of his ministry and banned for saying that apartheid was unjust.
“We now think he had it right,” Tuvel says.
She is not claiming that Oppenheimer is right and his critics are wrong. Her point is that “a (university) Council abandons those commitments once it seeks to remove a member for voicing a dissenting view, even, and especially, when that view is critical of the institution itself.”
She knows how punishing one dissenter can silence many others. During her ordeal, established academics wrote to her privately saying they were sorry for what she was going through and for not speaking out. Some said they just “could not handle it”.
Oliver Traldi, assistant professor at the University of Toledo’s Institute of American Constitutional Thought and Leadership and a signatory to the open letter, says that professional risks, especially the risk of being fired, are “particularly effective at silencing people”.
Universities that respect academic freedom “should not be in the business of imposing such costs”, he says.
If people like Oppenheimer, who are committed “to understanding the ins and outs of theories and arguments, not to any particular conclusion”, are punished for thinking and talking, Traldi asks, “who knows what other people are keeping quiet about?”
While the dispute at UCT turns on Israel, antisemitism, and Islamist activism, the principle at stake is much bigger.
Today, it is Oppenheimer and Ansara. Tomorrow, it could be any Council member whose views offend a different majority.
UCT may still invoke its history as a bastion of intellectual independence and academic freedom, but history is not a permanent entitlement,
By contemplating the expulsion of an elected Council member for his public views, UCT’s leadership makes a powerful case that it is no longer the bastion of academic freedom it believes itself to be.
The subcommittee can still prove that case wrong. It does not have to follow Navsa’s recommendations.
It would do well to heed Tuvel’s words. She has seen where the road leads.
Marika Sboros is a freelance investigative journalist. She started her career as a hard-news reporter on the Rand Daily Mail in Johannesburg.