Could Breaking Municipalities up be a Solution to South Africa’s Crisis of Local Government?
Warwick Grey
– November 20, 2026
5 min read

South Africa’s crisis of local government raises a question that receives relatively little attention. Are some of the country’s municipalities simply too large and complicated to govern effectively? Much of the debate about failing municipalities focuses on corruption, poor management, financial mismanagement, and political instability. But there is another possibility worth examining. Could changing the structure of local government itself improve accountability and service delivery?
To explore this question, The Common Sense has considered what might happen if a large metropolitan municipality were broken into several smaller local governments, with responsibility for neighbourhood services devolved to them while major infrastructure remained under coordinated management. Johannesburg provides a useful thought experiment. This is not a proposal to carve up the city, nor is it necessarily a practical reform under present circumstances. Rather, Johannesburg’s scale, complexity, and financial difficulties make it a useful example through which to test whether a different model of municipal government might work better.
The question is whether smaller municipalities, responsible for services closer to the communities they serve, could be more responsive and accountable than a single administration governing millions of people. Other major cities, including London and Tokyo, offer examples of systems in which local authorities manage neighbourhood services while larger metropolitan institutions coordinate infrastructure and services that cross municipal boundaries. Their experiences suggest that there may be alternatives to South Africa’s current model that are worth considering.
Johannesburg illustrates the problem of scale. A single municipal administration is responsible for a metropolis of about six million people. It must plan and maintain major infrastructure across the city while also managing rubbish collection, local roads, potholes, streetlights, and development applications in individual neighbourhoods. These are very different responsibilities, yet they fall under the same administration. When services fail, residents can struggle to establish which part of the municipality is responsible.
One proposal is to replace Johannesburg’s single municipality with between five and ten separate municipalities. Each would have its own elected council, mayor, budget, administration, and revenue base. The city’s seven existing administrative regions could help identify possible boundaries, but they should not automatically become the new municipalities. Boundaries would need to reflect established communities and whether each area could support a functioning administration and afford the services assigned to it. One possible arrangement would create a northern municipality covering Midrand and Fourways, a western municipality covering Randburg and Roodepoort, a separate municipality for Soweto, and a north-eastern municipality including Sandton and surrounding areas. Central, eastern, and southern Johannesburg could also form additional municipalities, depending on the financial and infrastructure assessment.
Smaller municipalities would not have to manage every service independently. They could take responsibility for local roads, rubbish collection, parks, planning, and development approvals. Major water and electricity networks, landfill sites, and transport links serve multiple areas and would need to remain coordinated through shared utilities or agreements between municipalities. This would put decisions about neighbourhood services in the hands of local councils without fragmenting the infrastructure on which the entire city depends.
London and Tokyo show how citywide coordination can coexist with smaller local governments. In London, a citywide authority is responsible for transport, strategic planning, policing, and fire services, alongside 32 councils (known as boroughs) that manage many everyday local services. In Tokyo, the metropolitan government oversees water, sewerage, and firefighting, while 23 councils (called special wards) operate as local governments. The lesson for Johannesburg is that the authority responsible for major infrastructure does not have to be the same institution that manages local roads, rubbish collection, and neighbourhood planning.
Any division would also have to ensure that poorer communities are not left in municipalities without enough revenue to provide services. Boundaries should not simply separate wealthy suburbs from poorer townships, which in the South African context would likely be politically unfeasible in any case. Sandton and Alexandra, for example, could fall within the same municipality, as could Killarney and the inner city. This would bring areas with different property values and revenue bases into the same local government. Municipalities with weaker revenue bases would also need support from national government through the local government equitable share, conditional grants, and other transfers.
Before any boundaries are drawn, a detailed financial and administrative assessment would be necessary. This would examine property values, rates revenue, commercial activity, service obligations, infrastructure assets, operating costs, and future investment needs. It would also determine how the city’s existing debt, assets, employees, pension obligations, and contracts should be divided. The number of new municipalities should be determined by this work, rather than chosen in advance. Without proper planning, Johannesburg could simply end up with several smaller administrations carrying the same financial and management problems as the existing one.
Breaking Johannesburg into smaller municipalities would not automatically fix its finances or restore failing services. It could, however, bring local government closer to residents and make it easier to identify who is responsible for delivering the services they depend on, provided the new municipalities are financially viable and shared infrastructure remains properly coordinated.
Johannesburg is only an example, used here to illustrate how a different model of local government might work. The broader question is whether South Africa’s current municipal boundaries and governance structures are still fit for purpose. With municipalities across the country struggling to maintain infrastructure, manage their finances, and deliver basic services, there is a case for reconsidering not only how local government is run, but also how it is organised. Breaking up larger municipalities, where practical and financially viable, is one option that deserves serious consideration as part of a wider effort to reform local government across South Africa.