What Cyril Doesn’t get About Elon

David Christianson

– November 20, 2026

3 min read

Ramaphosa wants Elon Musk to give back to South Africa, but overlooks why Musk built his businesses in the United States; an enabling environment that South Africa has failed to create.
What Cyril Doesn’t get About Elon
Image by Win McNamee - Getty Images

This is a paid article which your subscription is allowing you to read.

Cyril Ramaphosa thinks that the world’s richest man, Elon Musk, should “give” to South Africa because he was born here. He seems to have mistaken the world’s most successful serial tech entrepreneur for some sort of philanthropist.

In a rambling interview with Jonathan Karl of ABC News, conducted during the South African president’s current visit to Silicon Valley in California, Ramaphosa called on Musk to remember his South African roots and “contribute to the development of South Africa”. Musk was born and raised in Pretoria but left for Canada at the age of 17 in the late 1980s to avoid military conscription.

Ramaphosa seems to regard Musk as representing a charity, not a business. Worse, in the interview, he extended his argument to include moral blackmail.

“[Musk], being a white South African, maybe he did not really understand the harm that the apartheid policies did … the education that he would have received was much better education than what I received ... when the apartheid government spent R12 on his education, it spent R1 on my education”, Ramaphosa said.

So, according to the president, Musk should invest in South Africa because he was, in his youth, supposedly a “beneficiary” of apartheid. That apartheid was bad for everyone – including exiles like the 17-year-old Musk – is an insight that seems to escape Ramaphosa.

If Musk feels he owes anything to any country, it is surely the United States, which provided the enabling environment for his subsequent development. His companies, among them Tesla, SpaceX, and X (formerly Twitter), could probably not have been developed away from the tech ecosystem and markets offered by that country.

That surely is the point, one which Ramaphosa entirely misses. Musk is undoubtedly a gifted and able individual. But he has chosen to live in a place that has allowed his genius to flourish. Ramaphosa, perhaps more than anyone else, has failed to create such an enabling environment in South Africa. In fact, he has been party to the disabling of our potential.

Musk signalled his intention to invest in South Africa through Starlink, his high-speed satellite internet company, as long ago as 2021. But the sector regulator, the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA), insists that if it wants a licence, the company must surrender 30% of its equity to a local black partner. Starlink, like all other foreign corporations operating in South Africa, refuses to do so.

ICASA could offer an “equity equivalent” (contributions in education or supplier development), which has been the solution in the South African market for the likes of Microsoft and Amazon. But the regulator insists it can only do so if its founding legislation is amended. That task falls squarely into the lap of Ramaphosa’s government. It has failed to act in the five years since Starlink first expressed interest.

Starlink even said that it would be willing to offer its service for free to 5 000 rural schools in South Africa in perpetuity, but this has been rebuffed, unless Starlink meets various racial criteria.

Musk can deploy his capital however he sees fit. He can be expected to continue to invest in leading-edge enterprises, and it is even possible that he will find opportunities among the tech start-ups in the Stellenbosch-Somerset West corridor. But it in no way improves South Africa’s attractiveness as an investment destination to have a president indulging in moral one-upmanship. In fact, it leads directly to doubts about whether he has any understanding of what drives investment.

Subscribe to unlock this article

To support our journalism, and unlock all of our investigative stories and provocative commentary, subscribe below.

Common Sense Plus

R99 / month

Full access to insight, analysis, and data.

SUBSCRIBE

Common Sense Member

R349 / month

Help shape an organisation committed to our values.

SUBSCRIBE
ALREADY HAVE AN ACCOUNT?

More articles by David Christianson

More articles on Politics

WE MAKE SOUTH AFRICA MAKE SENSE.

HOME

OPINIONS

POLITICS

POLLS

GLOBAL

ECONOMICS

LIFE

SPORT

InstagramLinkedInXFacebook